Wednesday, August 20, 2008

The Day After

This blog has gotten a lot of feedback in the last 24 hours. If you haven't read the original story, read that first to catch up. Today, the story continues.

In addition to the outpouring of mirrors and support for preserving the information I discovered, I've also received some very helpful information from other Google hackers. Specifically, I was encouraged to check out the Chinese version of Google: google.cn. Presented here are the results, not all of which I can take credit for.

What about google.cn?


When I woke up this morning, I ran my existing search string against google.cn. Interestingly, I got back two spreadsheet results: the original spreadsheet I blogged about, zctc.xls, and a new spreadsheet I hadn't previously discovered, 05ticao.xls. Here's a screenshot.


A few hours later after moderating comments, I refreshed my search. And wow, was it eye opening.

Expunged entirely from google.cn's search index is my original find, zctc.xls. Down the memory hole. If the documents are false, why remove them? Why wipe their existence from the search index? I was intrigued. I decided to follow the trail of the second spreadsheet, 05ticao.xls.


Always one step ahead of me, the document was again missing from its original home, the home page of the General Administration of Sport of China. Undeterred, I decided to look again to Baidu to see if I could retrieve the results.


Could it be? More documentation? I followed the document cache link...


There's He Kexin again, listed with a birthday of 1-1-1994, fourteen years old. Running that line through Google Translate, the chances of a case of mistaken identity diminish rapidly:

799, BB He Kexin CC female AA 1994.1.01  Beijing and
Beijing Beijing Municipal Sports Bureau, First Note

It is my suspicion that First Note is a mistranslation of First Place, as her world class gymnastics record speaks for itself. For those working to cache these documents, the direct link to the Baidu cache, for as long as it lasts, is here: cache link (update Baidu cache is dead now, here's a mirror at heathershow.com.

Conclusions


What is this post really about? I don't really feel that it's about the gymnastics age limit, or even really about whether fraud occurred. At this point, I believe that any reasonable observer already understands that age records have been forged. This story now is really about Internet censorship, the act of removing evidence while at the same time claiming that the evidence is wrong. For the first time I watched search records shift under my feet like sand, facts draining down a hole in the Internet. Will this stand?

For those interested in pursuing facts on their own, I should at this point cite my inspiration. If Johnny is the godfather of Google hacking, then his seminal book on the subject can be considered the bible of the field. There's nothing I've done here that you can't teach yourself from that book. Who knows what else can be accomplished; I am one, but You are Many. Good luck.


Updates


  • The power of crowds is already hard at work. Check out this link found by Digg user Karate3409, posted in the Digg story on this blog: Link.

    10 何可欣 He Kexin 女 F 1994 11 1994  1  1 北京体育局
    Beijing Sports Bureau 武汉体育局
    Wuhan Sports Bureau 2年 2 years

    That's a nice piece of research!



I have no affiliation with this book, make no money from referrals, and all profits from its sale go directly to the organization Hackers for Charity. If you want to know where I got my start, well, there you go.

0 comments:

Post a Comment

By :
Free Blog Templates